By Chlotrudis Independent Film Society
Rating: 3.5 cats
Director: Mike Leigh
Starring: Alison Garland | Daniel May | Helen Coker | James Corden | Lesley Manville | Marion Bailey | Paul Jesson | Ruth Sheen | Sally Hawkins | Timothy Spall
Country: france, united_kingdom
Year: 2002
Running time: 128
IMDB: http://us.imdb.com/Details?0286261
Laura says: “After diversions with career girls and period performers, writer/director Mike Leigh returns to the working class of SECRETS & LIES and LIFE IS SWEET. Within the confines of a dreary South London housing unit, Leigh and his actors make the everyday a revelatory look at human behavior.
“Penny returns from her days as a supermarket cashier to make supper with Rachel, who works as a cleaner in a nursing home. Rory spends his days in front of the TV, or attacking the older but smaller Craig (Ben Crompton) in the courtyard. Penny’s attempts to shape up Rory are met with verbal abuse which Phil tells her to ignore. Penny’s gibes at Phil’s lack of ambition and work ethic drive him into a shell.
“Penny’s coworker, single mother Maureen (Ruth Sheen), has an optimistic outlook on life and returns her sullen teenage daughter Donna’s (Helen Coker) barbs with jokes. Donna goes out with Jason (Daniel Mays), a loutish thug lusted after by Samantha (Sally Hawkins), a sluttish tease and daughter of Phil’s mate Ron (Paul Jesson) and his alcoholic wife Carol (Marion Bailey). Oddball Craig follows Samantha like a puppy.
“These individuals are so caught up under the crushing weight of continuing their existence that they need a shakeup, some subtle, some seismic, to re-see those around them. As in life, not everything is wrapped up evenly or neatly. Leigh makes us feel like we’ve discovered behavioral science as character flaws’ causal roots become clear. As in the title, it is abundantly clear that life is better for those who think positively. This is most evident regarding Maureen against Penny with Phil’s ‘That’s life’ attitude balancing the seesaw.
“Once again, Leigh has gathered an ensemble who serve him well, with Spall’s Bassett a true hangdog hound of well meaning mediocrity. Spall shifts gears from the apologetic existence he’s created, crying that he’s ‘like a little tree without water,’ adding incredible depth to seemingly simple Phil. Leslie Manville conveys the wearying effect of a constant nagger so well, it takes a while to realize the potency of her unwitting toxin. Ruth Sheen’s Maureen emits the type of chummy, no-nonsense energy that makes for a stalwart friend or family member while Marion Bailey is almost scary in her rendition of a helpless, maudlin drunk. Robert Wilfort, Gary McDonald and Diveen Henry all make impressions in small roles as a doctor, cab company owner and dispatcher. Kathryn Hunter is terrific as Phil’s muse-like fare, who connects with him in unexpected ways.
“With ALL OR NOTHING, Leigh reminds us of those little things, so easy to forget, that mean everything.” 3 1/2 cats
Michael says: “Last week I caught ALL OR NOTHING, the latest film by Mike Leigh, also nominated this year for the new Buried Treasure Chlotrudis Award. After playing for one week last fall, ALL OR NOTHING disappeared from Boston-area theatres. Thanks to the Brattle Theatre for bringing it back!
“After his stunning musical diversion (TOPSY-TURVY), Leigh returns to the exploration of family in working-class England. Three families living in the same housing complex form the core of ALL OR NOTHING. Each family’s struggle to get by day in and day out is met differently. Some disconnect from their emotions, others drown their misery in alcohol, still others act out physically or sexually. Timothy Spall’s (last year’s Chlotrudis Awards nominee in the Best Supporting Actor category for INTIMACY) Phil and Lesley Manville’s Penny with their two overweight children form the central family. Spall drives a cab, while Manville works at a grocery store. Their older daughter cleans at a senior citizen’s home and their younger son watches tv and harasses the neighborhood kids. Penny’s love for Phil has run dry under the desolation of their lives, and she the everyday drag of her life threatens to consume her. Phil philosophizes and ekes out an existence that avoids direct emotional confrontation.
“Meanwhile, Penny’s friend Maureen remains upbeat and full of good humor, even when her daughter becomes involved in a dicey situation with a potentially abusive boyfriend. Things come to a head with a medical crisis, and the outpouring of emotion is torrential. Reminiscent of the brilliant SECRETS AND LIES, ALL OR NOTHING triumphs with its performances, and some amazing moments of raw emotion. Thank God for Maureen keeping things occasionally humorous.” 3 1/2 cats
Robin says: “Director/scenarist Mike Leigh is best known for his angst-driven, working class tales of day-to-day life in England (with the exception of his last film, the large scale musical homage to Gilbert & Sullivan, TOPSY-TURVY). The helmer returns to what he knows best in his study of Phil and Penny Basset (Timothy Spall and Lesley Manville), a taxi driver and Safeway clerk living a despairing, common law marriage. Tensions abound in the
tiny family until, one day, an unexpected emergency arises and unites the them in ALL OR NOTHING.
“While the Basset family, including daughter Rachel (Alison Garland) and son Rory (James Cordend), is the central subject for ALL OR NOTHING, the film is really a fairly large ensemble piece based in a block of council flats (a kind of government housing project). Besides the Bassets, there is Maureen (Ruth Sheen), Penny’s good friend and the only real ray of sunshine in all the characters. Her daughter, Donna (Helen Coker) is a sullen, argumentative young woman stuck in a relationship with a selfish, mean bloke – until she tells him she is pregnant.
“Samantha (Sally Hawkins) is sluttish looking teenager who hangs around the flats with an eye out for a good time. Her parents, who she loathes, are both lushes, particularly her mom, Carol (Marion Bailey), whose gin-soaked mind and body find it almost impossible to focus on life’s realities. There is also Cecile (Kathryn Hunter), a French lady (with an outrageous accent) whom Phil gives a ride and learns a thing or two from his passenger, and Jason (Daniel Mays) a shy local boy who loves Samantha but has trouble expressing himself except in a self-mutilating way.
“The unrelenting dourness and desperation of ALL OR NOTHING could be a turnoff, but in Leigh’s capable hands is fascinating to watch. With the exception of Maureen, there are few who you would honestly like because of the negative air that all possess. Spall, who, if you’ve followed his career, should eventually be a candidate for lifetime achievement, and once again shows his phenomenal talent with his hangdog, beaten look and utter helplessness. Manville is his opposite as Patty, who works hard and wants more from her life and her husband than just to get by. When Rory collapses in the apartment courtyard, the tension builds when Phil is nowhere to be found. Marion Bailey as Carol is pathetic and sad, a caricature of a character but one that elicits the sympathy one reserves for the chronically ill. The rest of the ensemble cast does well in their small roles.
“Leigh wraps things up a bit too perfunctorily with a ‘soon they will live happily ever after’ ending that smacks of artificiality after ll the angst we’ve been subjected to. The fine acting and steady hand of Mike Leigh lets this slide by, as do the under-resolved loose ends of the other characters. Even though the runtime is in excess of two hours, I never did find the film to be boring, just relentlessly depressing – until the slight upbeat swing at the end. “3 1/2 cats